Find Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY With Reviews

Discover the authentic flavor of Italy in the center of Brooklyn, New York, where renowned eateries offer mouthwatering cuisine made with real, fresh ingredients. Brooklyn offers a wide variety of dining alternatives, whether you're looking for a fancy dining experience or a more intimate trattoria. With our list of the best Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, New York, which are only available on Top Rated Choices, you can discover your next favorite spot to eat and delight in the vibrant atmosphere.

Home / Restaurants / Italian Restaurants / Best Italian Restaurants in Brooklyn, NY

Published By: Amy Meyers

Top Rated Choices Images - Top Rated Choices

Aurora Brooklyn

Aurora Brooklyn with Top Rated Choices
Aurora Brooklyn

Aurora Brooklyn

Rating: 4.4/5.0 (1.5k Reviews)

Address: 70 Grand St, Brooklyn, NY 11249, United States

Areas Served: Brooklyn, NY  and nearby areas

Phone: +1 718-388-5100

Service options: Outdoor seating, Great cocktails, Vegetarian options

Working Days and Hours:

  • Monday To Thursday : 11 PM – 12 PM,
  • Friday :  12 PM -11:30 PM 
  • Saturday- Sunday: 11 AM -10:30 PM

About Aurora Brooklyn

Aurora Brooklyn, a little Williamsburg restaurant with a Tuscan flair, offers rustic elegance and real Italian cuisine. Aurora was founded in 2003 and offers seasonal Italian food made using traditional recipes and fresh ingredients. From informal lunches to romantic dinners, our cozy dining area and verdant garden provide the ideal backdrop for any event. Among the standout dishes, the Osso Buco and Cacciucco, a traditional Tuscan seafood stew, are absolute must-tries.

Additionally, their handmade tagliatelle with truffle cream sauce is a crowd favorite. One of the friendliest Italian restaurants in Brooklyn, New York, for authentic Italian foodies, it offers a wide variety of excellent wines, handcrafted drinks, and regional beers.

Osteria Brooklyn

Osteria Brooklyn with Top Rated Choices
Osteria Brooklyn

Osteria Brooklyn

Rating: 4.5/5.0 (904 Reviews)

Address: 458 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205, United States

Areas served: Brooklyn, NY  and nearby areas

Phone:+1 646-750-9156

Service options: Happy-hour food, Great cocktails, Vegetarian options

Working Days and Hours:

  • Monday To Friday : 12 PM – 10 PM, 
  • Saturday -Sunday: 11:30 AM -10 PM 

About Osteria Brooklyn

Locals and tourists looking for real Italian food in Brooklyn have swiftly come to love Osteria Brooklyn since it opened in August 2020. Situated in Clinton Hill along Myrtle Avenue, the restaurant serves inventive Italian cuisine in a welcoming yet lively setting. A local insider tip: the best time to visit is during weekdays for lunch, when the ambiance is more relaxed, and you can enjoy personalized interactions with the chefs.

Chef Marco, who hails from Milan, often shares his secret of making the perfect Fettuccine Osteria—cooked in a Parmigiano Reggiano cheese wheel and garnished with truffles. In addition, the restaurant offers wood-fired pizza, fresh oysters, and delectable desserts such as meringue cake and tiramisu. Osteria Brooklyn epitomizes contemporary Italian dining in the center of Brooklyn with its picturesque surroundings and superb cuisine.

Do You want to List Your Business FREE At Top Rated Choices? Click on Add Your Business