Explore the Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo, NY With Top Rated Choices

Savor the flavors of Italy in the center of Buffalo, New York, where a love of real food and friendly service converge. Buffalo's Italian restaurants, which range from classic family-run establishments to fine dining experiences, honor Italian history with handcrafted pasta, distinctive sauces, and fine wines. There are countless ways to sate your cravings, whether you're organizing a family feast or a romantic meal. With Top Rated Choices, you can find a carefully curated list of best Italian restaurants with Buffalo, NY and enjoy the best of Italian cuisine.

Home / Restaurants / Italian Restaurants / Best Italian Restaurants in Buffalo, NY

Published By: Emily Maynard

Top Rated Choices Images - Top Rated Choices

Chef's Restaurant

Chef's Restaurant of Buffalo NY - Top Rated Choices
Chef's Restaurant of Buffalo NY

Chef's Restaurant

Rating: 4.5/5.0 (3.6K Reviews)

Service options: Private dining room, Great cocktails, Vegetarian options

Address: 291 Seneca St, Buffalo, NY 14204, United States

Phone:+1 716-856-9187

Working Days and Hours:

  • Tuesday To Friday : 11 AM – 8 PM, 
  • Saturday : 3 PM -8 PM
  • Sunday -Monday : Closed 

About Chef's Restaurant

Chef’s Restaurant, a Buffalo icon since 1923, combines comfort and history. Known for its famous spaghetti parm, thick sauces, and freshly baked bread, this family-friendly spot has served generations with hearty Italian-American fare. With banquet services, drive-thru pickup, catering, and dine-in options, Chef’s turns every meal into a family gathering. It remains a favorite among Buffalo residents seeking traditional Italian comfort food after a century of culinary excellence.

Lombardo

Lombardo restaurant in buffalo ny - Top Rated Choices
Lombardo

Lombardo

Rating: 4.7/5.0 (743 Reviews)

Service options: Reservations required,  Outdoor seating,  Private dining room

Address: 1198 Hertel Ave, Buffalo, NY 14216, United States

Phone: +1 716-873-4291

Price per person: $50–100

Working Days and Hours:

  • Tuesday To Saturday : 5 PM – 10  PM,
  • Monday : Closed

About Lombardo

Dine in one of Buffalo’s most cherished restaurants and discover the charm of real Italian cuisine. For over 40 years and three generations, Ristorante Lombardo has stayed true to its origins since 1975. With historic decor and a beautiful copper ceiling, this cozy restaurant offers a memorable old-world atmosphere. Guests enjoy savory sauces, homemade pastas, and a carefully chosen wine list. Ristorante Lombardo stands out among Buffalo’s best Italian restaurants for its rich history and dedication to authentic flavors.

Do You want to List Your Business FREE At Top Rated Choices? Click on Add Your Business